01-Jan-2012, 6:47 PM
Overall I think CCLP3 takes the top prize for me here, because of it's great ideas and original concepts. CCLP2 had obvious issues with MS-only mechanics such as invalid tiles, which I'm fine with except that it gave rise to weird combinations such as items underneath floor and bombs under water which need to be erased via monster transparency. And CC1 was great but of course it was first and didn't have nearly as much exploration of puzzle concepts. I have a feeling when CCLP1 comes out it will qualify for the top of the pole for me, because what I hear of it sounds really fun.