CCLP1 Voting Lists and Nominations

[jblewis]

My level FFW from Ida4 is on the limbo list due to unequality - slide delay. But that whole level, just as REW, is based on levels from CC1. I sort of think that this inequality would be ok for that reason. I mean, this was in the original set.

I guess I could swap that whole section with something else... But anyway, maybe these levels aren't suitable for CCLP1 since they are nothing else than copies of parts of levels from the original set.

It was in the original set, but when it was designed, Lynx mode was the only way to play CC, and slide delay didn't exist. Unfortunately, slide delay (along with a number of other behaviors) seemed to be overlooked when MSCC was created. The litmus test that's been used for ruleset incompatibility in CCLP3 and CCLP1 is whether or not a level contains a significant difference in difficulty across rulesets. The original Block Buster is much harder in MSCC and has earned the distinction of being one of the most difficult CC1 levels ever just because of that one section. My suggestion would be to replace that section with one from another CC1 level; it would probably increase FFW's chances of doing well in voting without such a timing-intensive section at the end.

That's a valid point. Which is why I'll actually nominate FFW for the Whitelist. My stance has always been looser on lucky timing, slide delay and guesswork anyway

It doesn't need to be nominated for the whitelist; it's already tentatively whitelisted by being on the limbo list and will be as long as the aforementioned issue is corrected.

CCLP1 Staff,

I've fixed Level 35 which is on the Limbo list. As for Level 78, which teeth that is hard to evade? The upper one or the lower one?

The lower one, as the upper one can easily be killed in the water in both rulesets, whereas the lower one can't in Lynx because of the fire.

I also updated DanielB-Lynx, changing what Bowman suggested. I nominate Aim and Glint (if I'm allowed, because it's not technically my set).

Of course - you're not the designer, so it's totally okay!