Walls of CCLP3 discussion

[Flareon350]

2 hours ago, Kataac said:

#20 Gloomy Minute Village (walls from #25 Recess) Not a personal vote from me. Levels that use blobs in tight spaces are very hard to do right, and this one just doesn't work, especially when you add a tight time limit. I haven't solved this one, and have no interest in doing so.

#22 Chipyard (most walls from #17 Lot in Life) The concept is very clever, but the execution is very strange and it feels like it was forced into the wall layout

#28 Hang Glider Smuggler (walls from #140 Yet Another Yet Another Puzzle) When I first played this, I accidentally pushed the block with the hint and thought I had blocked off something important, so I replayed the level only to find out there was nothing under the block. While I really disagree with that part of the level, the rest was pretty solid, albeit a <i>very</i> loose adaptation of YAYAP.

#29 Broken Floppy Disk (walls from #21 Mud and Water) I'm not really sure what the title has to do with the level

#30 Digitized Disaster (teleports? from #35 MonsterMaze) Not too sure about this one.

I think Gloomy Minute Village is a good idea of a dodging level and it works pretty well! Not to say it's perfect because it's far from that. It's another level concept I otherwise would have never done outside of this set (like Blurry) and honestly, it's one I now really like! The time limit being tight is intentional and even with the dodging it really isn't that hard of a level either. (Disclaimer: I don't consider this a blob dodging level but they affect the pattern of the others which makes it interesting). Maybe this is a little on the luck side of things but its not unreasonable. Imagine this on a greater scale then maybe this will be appreciated a bit more. If not, then oh well I can't please everyone! This is what I wanted. And as far as you not having interest in completing it - all I will say is you'll never have the satisfaction of 100%ing the set if you don't

I love the concept of Chipyard and am proud of the puzzle. It is very forced because the walls weren't that interesting to use by themselves.

You disagree with something of Hang Glider Smuggler that was 100% optional to players...? I guess I see where you're coming from but you chose to restart instead of playing out the rest of the level which could have been solved. also I'm not seeing how any of this is an adaptation of YAYAP. Because it uses blocks, even though it's clearly a glider themed level?

Broken Floppy Disk is titled as such because the level looked like a Floppy Disk to me.

Digitized Disaster uses teleports that were in place of the toggle walls from MonsterMaze because I had zero ideas for the toggle walls.

Thank you again for the feedback!