CCLP1 Voting Lists and Nominations

[rockdet]

It doesn't need to be nominated for the whitelist; it's already tentatively whitelisted by being on the limbo list

Yeah duh

[Reynaldi]

The lower one, as the upper one can easily be killed in the water in both rulesets, whereas the lower one can't in Lynx because of the fire.

Oh okay, I'll fix it then

[jblewis]

Hey everyone,

What does everyone think of the following potential deadlines?

Friday, May 24 - blacklist nominations end, last chance to make changes to levels not requested by staff

Friday, May 31 - limbo list correction period ends

This would allow voting to start on June 1, providing no major issues come up.

[M11k4]

Sounds good to me!

[Flareon350]

I'm okay with this.

[jbdude55]

Agreed.

[jblewis]

Evening, everyone! A few updates for you tonight:

- kidsfair, Lessinath, and Places have been renumbered across all lists as per their recent set updates. We're still re-evaluating some of the newly revised Places levels, though.

- MikeL3's and Rosa1's new and ineligible levels have been added to the ineligible list.

- Joe's CCLP1 Entries has been updated! We completely missed the fact that some new levels were added before the deadline last year. Thanks to micronexer for catching this. Levels 19, 21, 23, and 25 are on the whitelist, while levels 1, 20, and 22 have been added to the limbo list, and 26 and 27 are still being evaluated.

- I've added a number of limbo list levels to the whitelist! These levels have either been corrected, were mistakenly placed on the limbo list to begin with, or their designers made a successful case against the reasons for their placement on the limbo list. They are:

ajmiam-pit-of-100-tiles* 41 Constant Vigilance!
ajmiam-pit-of-100-tiles* 43 Checkmate?
ajmiam-pit-of-100-tiles* 79 Wormhole
ArchieP1 106 SPECIAL TANKS TO
ArchieP1 112 OUT OF THE FRYING PAN
ArchieP1 135 PACKED PROBLEM
BHLS1Lynx 20 Close Call
BHLS1Lynx 45 Back and Forth
BHLS1Lynx 57 Circling the Exit
BHLS1Lynx 66 Sokokoban
BHLS2 12 4 ways to win
DanielB-Lynx 75 GLINT
Egyptian_Motif_LYNX_71 27 The Hood
Egyptian_Motif_LYNX_71 34 Four Corners
Egyptian_Motif_LYNX_71 56 Filling in the Gaps
Egyptian_Motif_LYNX_71 140 Honeycomb
Extra_Extra 20 THE KEY TO THE CITY
JRB_CCLP1 19 NET
kidsfair 12 This and That
kidsfair 27 To Be the Best
kidsfair 40 Coming Full Circle
Lessinath_CCLP1_final 84 Broken Portal
Lessinath_CCLP1_final 93 Mountain Cavern
MikeL3 16 Backtrack
MikeL3 27 Teleporting Madness I
Places 1 GARDEN OF EDEN
ReyCCLP1 35 Amphibious Assault
ReyCCLP1 78 Drive-Thru
TomPCCLP1 17 Bowling Alleys
TomPCCLP1 24 Fortress II
TomPCCLP1 32 Flooded

- I've added several levels to the whitelist after going back and re-evaluating them, seeing new changes that designers have made in recent weeks, and hearing arguments for inclusion on the whitelist. These levels are:


ajmiam-the-other-100-tiles-cclp1* 10 The Maze that Turned On and Off
CCLP1_Lessons 3 Intro: Out of Control
Chip56 1 LESSON THE 1ST
DanielB-Lynx 1 LESSON 1 - CHIPS
DanielB-Lynx 4 LESSON 4 - BLOCKS
Egyptian_Motif_LYNX_71 31 Good Morton
Egyptian_Motif_LYNX_71 41 Syzygy
Egyptian_Motif_LYNX_71 51 Messerschmitt
Egyptian_Motif_LYNX_71 52 Tesla Coil - Part A
Egyptian_Motif_LYNX_71 94 Salt, Sulphur, Mercury, Lead
Egyptian_Motif_LYNX_71 104 Smorgasbord
Egyptian_Motif_LYNX_71 130 7 Seals
Egyptian_Motif_LYNX_71 137 Notebook on Desk
Egyptian_Motif_LYNX_71 139 Magnet
Egyptian_Motif_LYNX_71 142 The Factory Revisited
JRB_CCLP1 11 THE ADVENTURE
kidsfair 22 Transylvania
kidsfair 26 Head for a Dime
Places 3 MAYAN PYRAMID
Places 12 THE EVERGLADES
Places 13 THE LOUVRE MUSEUM
Places 20 THE "BIG APPLE"
Places 22 ROBBEN ISLAND
TomPCCLP1 5 Rainbow Door Key
TomPCCLP1 12 Cold Fear
TomPCCLP1 65 The Labyrinth

- And, of course, I've made sure to whitelist all of the levels that have received at least two nominations so far! They are:

AndrewR1 21 Reflecting
ArchieP1 117 AGAIN AND AGAIN
bigoto7 82 Toggletank Factory
DanielB-Lynx 20 MYSTERY WALL
DanielB-Lynx 71 AIM
JBLP1 61 A Study in Pink
JBLP1 99 Japanese Game Show
JCCLP 104 Duplex
LizzyBCCLP1 29 the caves
tensorpudding-cclp1 22 Changing Lanes II
TomPCCLP1 1 All Bit Busters Go To Heaven
TomPCCLP1 4 Runaway Train
TomPCCLP1 26 Christmas Eve
TomPCCLP1 54 Route 280
TS0 3 Tree of Life
TS0 7 Spring
TS0 8 Dig for Fire
TS0 15 Metal Harbor
TS0 21 Propaganda
TS1 10 Chip Crossing
TS1 11 Blockorama
TS1 33 This Too Shall Pass
TS1 35 Judgement

- As part of the re-evaluation, I've added some formerly blacklisted levels to the limbo list as well. They are:


Egyptian_Motif_LYNX_71 38 1 Waterfall
Egyptian_Motif_LYNX_71 70 Flowchart
Egyptian_Motif_LYNX_71 131 Route 66
Grant 8 DOUBLE DIVERSION
Joe's CCLP1 Entries 1 LEARN YOUR LESSONS
Joe's CCLP1 Entries 20 WILD MOUSE
Joe's CCLP1 Entries 22 GRIN AND BEAR IT
kidsfair 37 Blue around the Clock

Let me know if there's anything I've missed. I'm calling it a night tonight.

[quiznos00]

I'd like to nominate Bearing II in AndrewR1.

[Eric119]

About two levels in my set:

Gliders and Gliders: I suspect the main reason this level was blacklisted is the difficulty with getting the chip at (7, 15). Would the staff consider moving this level to the whitelist if the number of gliders surrounded this chip were halved (i.e., one glider in the outer ring, two in the inner)? Also, was the glider at (12, 19) considered a problem?

Access Denied: Again, perhaps removing the balls at the center and some others? (Not sure if I'd make this change. I'm kinda partial to the current design of the level.)

[jblewis]

Yes on all counts. I'll evaluate both levels if you make any further changes, but I'd be happy to add these two levels to my own nomination list either way.